Tax policy matters to population and financial growth, prosperity and stability. For those reasons, the Tax Foundation’s annual State Tax Competitiveness Index rankings should serve as a road map for policymakers about how to reform their individual codes to improve the lives of the people in their states.
Marta MossburgThe 2027 ranking shows a wide divergence in the Mountain West, with Wyoming ranking first, Montana seventh, Idaho thirteenth, and Washington a dismal forty-seventh – and this is before the new unconstitutional income tax passed by the Washington state legislature this year is factored into the survey.
First, the best: Wyoming scored the highest because it does not have a corporate or individual income tax. It scored in the lower half of the 50 states for its unemployment insurance tax rate and property taxes. Of note, if Proposition 1— which would have exempted 50 percent of a property owner’s primary residence from property taxes—had passed at the ballot earlier this month, the ranking likely would have been impacted in future years because of changes to income or sales taxes to compensate for the loss of revenue.
Its 39th rank for property taxes points to the need to enact levy limits and other reforms to constrain local government spending and protect taxpayers.
Despite major income tax reforms, Montana fell two spots in this year’s survey, from fifth to seventh, largely because the state uses federal taxable income as the basis for state income tax liability. This includes no taxes on tips and overtime, which shrank the tax base. Montana is also continuing to implement a tiered and confusing property tax system that taxes different portions of residential, commercial, and agricultural properties at different rates rather than at one flat rate.
A bright spot is the fact that lawmakers lowered the top income tax rate and eliminated the marriage penalty. The recent push by Gov. Greg Gianforte to create one lower, flat income tax rate could positively impact the Treasure State’s rankings in future years.
Like Montana, Idaho’s ranking dropped despite ongoing tax relief. The Gem State fell four places to the 13th spot this year, mainly because it decided to exempt taxes on tips and overtime by adopting House Bill 559 in 2026, which aligned the state tax code with the federal One Big Beautiful Bill Act. As a result, the state is estimated to forgo about $155 million in the current fiscal year without boosting much growth.
Washington earned its 47th rank, one lower than last year, because of adopting digital advertising into the sales tax base. This change crowned it last of the 50 states in the sales tax bracket. It did improve five slots in the property and wealth tax rankings by cutting the top estate tax rate to 20 percent from 35 percent. State lawmakers adopted a 9.9 percent tax on income over $1 million in 2026, which takes effect in 2028. If allowed to stand, it would significantly impact its status in the study.
Washington has already become Idaho’s top feeder state for new residents, overtaking California, according to U.S. Census data, showing how people vote on tax policy with their feet.
As the study notes, “a well-structured tax code won’t make the Wyoming Basin a metropolis, nor will poor tax structure make Manhattan a ghost town. But tax structure does play a role in a state’s economic successes or failures, and often a substantial one. Every state can benefit from a simple, neutral, transparent, pro-growth tax structure.”
Given the higher spending favored by the new majority in both Houses of Congress, it is more important than ever for states to enact pro-growth tax codes to inoculate themselves from any tax changes at the federal level. The falling ranks for Montana and Idaho show that ongoing attention to tax competitiveness is essential as other states also act.
Policymakers throughout the Mountain West—and especially those in Washington—should use the Index to see what reforms boost income and growth and avoid those that dampen competitiveness and send residents packing.
Marta Mossburg is a research fellow at Mountain States Policy Center, an independent research organization based in Idaho, Montana, Washington and Wyoming. Online at mountainstatespolicy.org.







Comments
Loading comments…