Opinion

Opinion: Vancouver’s impact fee deferral is a step forward, but misses the larger affordability challenge

Mark Harmsworth says Vancouver's action deserves recognition as a positive step, but it should also be seen as the beginning of a broader discussion rather than the final solution

By · November 18, 2026
Share this story
FacebookEmail
Opinion: Vancouver’s impact fee deferral is a step forward, but misses the larger affordability challenge
Mark Harmsworth writes that delayed payment eases developer financing but does not substantially reduce housing development costs. Image courtesy Washington Policy Center

The Vancouver City Council's recent decision to allow developers to defer payment of impact fees until later in the construction process is a welcome acknowledgment that local governments play a significant role in determining housing costs. By improving cash flow and reducing up-front financing needs, the policy may help some projects move forward that otherwise would have struggled under current economic conditions.

Mark HarmsworthMark Harmsworth

However, while the measure is a positive first step, it does not substantially reduce the cost of housing development.

Impact fees remain the same. Developers are still responsible for paying the full amount. The difference is that payment is delayed, reducing carrying costs and interest expenses associated with financing those fees during construction. That financial relief can be valuable, particularly at a time when elevated borrowing costs have made many housing projects difficult to pencil out. But deferral is not the same as reform.

Using the example given by City Staff, a 100-unit development would save $60,000 in financing costs, or approximately $600 per home. Again, a welcome savings, but not earth shattering on a $500,000 home.

Washington continues to face a severe housing shortage driven by a combination of rising construction costs, lengthy permitting timelines, restrictive zoning regulations, and increasing local fees and taxes. The cumulative effect of these policies has been to raise the cost of every new home brought to market. Ultimately, those costs are passed on to homebuyers and renters.

The critical question for policymakers should be whether regulatory requirements and local fees are necessary, proportional, and structured in a way that encourages housing supply. Deferring impact fees may improve project cash flow, but it does nothing to reduce the underlying regulatory burden that developers face. Permitting requirements, environmental reviews, land-use restrictions, parking mandates, design standards, and impact fees themselves still add substantial costs to housing production.

If Vancouver wants to meaningfully increase housing affordability, the next conversation should focus on reducing unnecessary regulatory barriers and reviewing whether current impact fee levels accurately reflect infrastructure needs. Policymakers should also examine opportunities to streamline permit approvals and eliminate duplicative requirements that delay construction and increase carrying costs.

Housing affordability improves when more homes are built. While impact fee deferrals may help some projects move forward, they are best viewed as a financing adjustment rather than a structural reform. Real progress will require addressing the regulations and fees that increase the cost of building housing in the first place.

In that sense, Vancouver's action deserves recognition as a positive step, but it should also be seen as the beginning of a broader discussion rather than the final solution.

Mark Harmsworth is the director of the Small Business Center at the Washington Policy Center.

Comments

Loading comments…