Politics

Legal showdown set as schools weigh protecting girls sports initiative

Washington voters passed Initiative 638 on November 3 by roughly a 56% to 44% margin

By Carleen Johnson · November 20, 2026
Share this story
FacebookEmail
Listen to this story
Initiative 638 Hearing Set Dec. 3 as Districts Plan Rollout
0:000:00
Legal showdown set as schools weigh protecting girls sports initiative
A sign urging passage of I-638 is seen at a recent event. Photo courtesy Carleen Johnson/The Center Square Washington

On the same day an initiative to limit girls sports to biological females is set to take effect, a judge will consider a request to put the measure on hold pending the outcome of a lawsuit brought by opponents.

Washington voters passed Initiative 638 on November 3 by roughly a 56% to 44% margin.

The hearing will take place before King County Superior Court Judge Maureen McKee on Dec. 3, the same day the Secretary of State is expected to certify the initiative that will prevent biological males from competing in girls’ and women’s sports.

McKee was appointed to the position in 2018 by former Gov. Jay Inslee.

The Washington Education Association-the state teachers union, The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and several Seattle Public Schools families are the plaintiffs challenging the initiative.

This week, the Washington State Medical Association also joined plaintiffs in urging the court to put the measure on hold.

“While we recognize the public’s concern for fairness in sports, as statewide medical organizations we are deeply troubled by the initiative’s mandate imposing medically unnecessary examinations and verification requirements on girls participating in school sports,” wrote WSMA in a Nov. 17 news release.

If Judge McKee grants an injunction on Dec. 3, it will put the initiative’s implementation on hold while the lawsuit proceeds.

As reported by The Center Square, supporters of the initiative have been critical of Attorney General Nick Brown assigning Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner, a law firm that has defended trans-rights and LGBTQ issues, to defend I-638.

“Appointing outside counsel—known as a Special Assistant Attorney General—is a common step we take when our office cannot handle a case ourselves, whether because of a conflict of interest, a need for specialized expertise, or simply because of workload,” wrote Brown.

Attorneys with Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) have asked to intervene in the case on behalf of several female athletes from Washington high schools, in defense of I-638, suggesting the outside counsel may not mount a vigorous defense.

"It's appropriate that those most affected by this situation, which is the girls…that they should be the ones who have their voices heard before the court," said ADF attorney Jonathan Scruggs in a Monday interview with The Center Square.

As of Friday, it remains unclear if Judge McKee will allow ADF attorneys to be heard in the matter.

Meantime, some school districts are positioning to implement 638 immediately, assuming the measure is not put on hold.

A King County judge will consider on Dec. 3 a request to put I-638 on hold pending the outcome of opponents' lawsuit.
A King County judge will consider on Dec. 3 a request to put I-638 on hold pending the outcome of opponents' lawsuit.

“When it comes to Kennewick, we had an overwhelming amount of people vote yes. I think it was almost 75%. And so, we thought it was important for our community to understand that, yes, we are going to implement these changes December 3rd, regardless of the lawsuit or pending lawsuit, we are going to do this,” said Gabe Galbraith, president of the Kennewick School Board.

He told The Center Square their district has been on the front lines of the fight to protect Title IX for years now.

“We obviously have to wait for the court order...depending on the outcome of that, we're going to move forward," he said. "Now, if nothing's done and it's just kind of sitting there, we're implementing. We've already got plans in place for what that's going to look like for us."

This week, the state’s governing body for interscholastic K-12 sports, the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association (WIAA) said students currently participating in winter girls’ sports will need a medical provider to attest that their “biological sex is female” by Dec. 3 to continue competing.

The new form will require a medical provider to check a box verifying the student is biologically male or female.

Let’s Go Washington, which backed the initiative, told The Center Square in a Friday interview that the new WIAA form should put to bed further arguments from opponents who before and after the election tried to convince people that invasive exams would be required to participate in sports.

“The medical eligibility form is something that's been happening forever. And when they send over that medical eligibility form, they don't say, this student can't play X sport because of this kind of disease, right? They just say, can the student play the sport? Yes or no? Do they have any restrictions? Yes or no? That's it,” said LGW Executive Director Darren Littell. “And if you look at the form that the WIAA put out, it says exactly that. It’s checked through the medical history.”

Seattle Public Schools isn't directly involved in the lawsuit, but the district has submitted a friend-of-the-court brief in support of the injunction.

SPS Board of Directors previously adopted a resolution urging legal counsel to look into 638 and potential conflicts with other state laws.

On Monday, Nov. 23 in Battle Ground in Southwest Washington, the school board is expected to consider a parent sponsored resolution that like Kennewick, would state they intend to implement 638 on Dec. 3, barring a court preventing them from doing so.

The resolution was offered by Sheona Lowe, the mother of a 15-year-old Battle Ground High School cross-country athlete, who was among about a dozen runners who refused to run against a biological male athlete from Camas High School who switched from the boy’s team to run with the girl’s mid-season.

“I’m hoping that she doesn't have to go through another season of this because she said she'd give up cross country if this was the thing,” said Lowe in a Nov. 9 interview with The Center Square.

The preliminary injunction hearing on Initiative 638 is scheduled for December 3, 2026, at 9:00 a.m. before Judge Maureen McKee in King County Superior Court.

This report was first published by The Center Square Washington.

Comments

Loading comments…