Politics

Legal battle over Washington’s income tax heats up as unions seek late entry

With a matter of weeks before a scheduled hearing on the case, public-sector labor unions are petitioning to join the fight in defense of the tax

By Carleen Johnson · November 16, 2026
Share this story
FacebookEmail
Legal battle over Washington’s income tax heats up as unions seek late entry
A supporter of repealing Washington state's income tax is seen at an event in July. A a Klickitat County Superior Court judge will soon oversee a hearing in the lawsuit against Washington’s income tax as a challenge to the constitutionality of the law proceeds. Photo courtesy Carleen Johnson/The Center Square

In less than three months, a Klickitat County Superior Court judge will oversee a hearing in the lawsuit against Washington’s new income tax as a challenge to the constitutionality of the law proceeds.

The suit was filed in April 2026, and is backed by the Citizen Action Defense Fund, on behalf of the National Federation of Independent Business the Building Industry Association of Washington the Ethnic Chamber of Commerce Coalition, the Yakima Klickitat Farm Association, and others arguing the tax violates state constitutional property tax rules and precedent.

But now with a matter of weeks before a scheduled hearing on the case, public-sector labor unions are petitioning to join the fight in defense of the tax.

The Washington Education Association and the Washington State Labor Council are the two main labor union groups that last week filed for the right to intervene in the case to defend the income tax.

Neither group responded Monday to requests for comment.

CADF Executive Director Jackson Maynard tells The Center Square the motion to intervene comes too late in the game.

“We will likely oppose that motion. It's just so late in the process. They’ve waited on this for six months that our lawsuit’s been pending, and now after discovery is completed, and we’re at the stage of being ready to brief this thing as a matter of law, they want to sort of swoop in. That’s just not appropriate at this stage,” said Maynard.

Earlier this month, Washington voters rejected initiative I-645, which would have repealed the tax of 9.9% on income over $1 million, by a vote of about 58% to 42%.

Maynard said supporters of the income tax may have been waiting to see if the initiative was passed before deciding to request intervention in the lawsuit, but suggested the two challenges are entirely unrelated.

“They've got to meet the standard to be able to intervene. If they want to file an amicus brief, a friend of the court brief, to make whatever policy arguments they want, they can still do that so they can still have their say in court," he said.

"The question is whether they should be allowed to actually enter the court as attorneys and be able to brief the case and potentially engage in discovery or be subject to discovery,” Maynard added. “We don’t think so.”

Washington's new income tax law is set to take effect in 2028 if the law survives the lawsuit, and is projected to bring an estimated $3 billion each year into the state from some 25,000 households.

Proponents argue it makes the tax system fairer and life more affordable for working families.

“At a time when many of us are struggling to afford the basics, mega-millionaires and extremist groups are trying to hurt millions of Washingtonians by taking away the biggest state tax cuts they’ve received in many years," said Invest in WA Now when the lawsuit was filed in April.

Economic Opportunity Institute, which also backed the income tax posted on their website: “A millionaire’s tax is the first step towards achieving a progressive tax code that generates revenue for the infrastructure Washingtonians rely on for an affordable and meaningful life: high-quality public education, ample child care, affordable health care, and more housing options for families.”

Maynard at CADF told The Center Square their main argument will be that the income tax is in violation of the state Constitution.

“It is very clear that the income tax that was passed by the legislature last session violates the state Constitution. Both Article 7, Section 1 and 2."

Section 1 of Article 7 concerns the uniformity requirement, which requires taxes on the same class of property to be applied uniformly.

Opponents contend that a graduated tax or a tax with a deduction/threshold, such as taxing income above $1 million, is not uniform across all taxpayers.

Section 2 of Article 7 caps property taxes at 1% of property value. Opponents argue that taxing income at a rate of 9.9% exceeds this constitutional limit.

The case is expected to eventually reach the Washington Supreme Court, with an appeal expected from whichever side is unsuccessful in the lower court.

As reported by The Center Square, internal communications revealed how Democratic supporters of the income tax worked behind the scenes with the Washington Attorney General's Office to design legislation that would serve as a legal test case to the Supreme Court.

This report was first published by The Center Square Washington.

Comments

Loading comments…