Elizabeth Hovde of the Washington Policy Center says the governor is confident his strict COVID-19-related mandates have been responsible for saving lives, but data do not back up these claims
Elizabeth Hovde
Washington Policy Center
Oregon announced it was getting rid of its COVID-19 vaccine mandate on more than 400,000 state employees in March of 2022 — more than a year ago. Then-Gov. Kate Brown explained she was rescinding an “extraordinary emergency” that was no longer necessary.
King County and the City of Seattle no longer require proof of vaccination against COVID-19 as a condition of employment, either. King County Executive Dow Constantine said in an announcement, “With high vaccination rates and effective, updated boosters available, we are in a different place in the pandemic, and our policies and regulations will change to reflect the best information we have available today, as they have throughout the last three years.” He said that in February.
Gov. Jay Inslee must have emerged from a burrow and seen his shadow, as he is allowing the state’s vaccine-mandate winter to carry on. In fact, he never wants it to end. He directed the Office of Financial Management to craft rules for a permanent COVID-19 vaccine mandate. The rules have been written — effective Nov. 4 — and a COVID vaccine is now a requirement for taxpayer-funded employment in state executive and small cabinet agencies.
The mandate is foolish, unfair and not based on science. Unvaccinated and vaccinated people contract, are hospitalized and die with COVID.
Minus legislative progress on ending the mandate — and seeing the governor double, triple and quadruple down on the thing — I’ve implored the State Board of Health to use its influence to redirect the misguided, outdated policy. Here are my public comments to the board today for its April 12 meeting:
“Thanks for your time today, Chair Grellner and board members. I’m Elizabeth Hovde with the Washington Policy Center.
I am here to ask for your intervention and influence on the governor’s permanent vaccine mandate as a condition for employment.
The governor directed the Office of Financial Management to write rules that are now in place for a permanent vaccine mandate for state employees in executive and small cabinet agencies. The governor has also included the mandate, along with bonuses for voluntarily chosen boosters, in contract negotiations with labor. The two policies together send a confusing health message that is not based on science.
COVID-19 mask and emergency orders have ended or are winding down; the CDC removed its policy distinctions between the vaccinated and the unvaccinated months ago; we know that those most in health danger from COVID are the elderly, not working-age people; and we know that both vaccinated and unvaccinated people can spread and contract COVID-19.
A vaccinated state worker who is still employed by the state can contract and spread and get sick from COVID-19, while an unvaccinated worker might not.
It’s past time for the state to stop punishing and limiting the working options of the COVID-unvaccinated, and I hope you can help. Vaccines appear to help some with hospitalization and death, but a vaccine mandate on working-age people does not. Further, there are other health behaviors that impact workers in our state workforce, but those behaviors don’t get them fired.
The mandate has caused state staffing problems for no demonstrable public health benefit. More than 2,000 state workers’ careers ended because of the vaccine mandate. Instead of following the science, a permanent vaccine mandate will exclude potential new hires, too.
Last I checked, the Department of Health’s COVID-19 vaccination dashboard reports that 30 percent of the state’s total population has not completed a COVID-19 primary series. Excluding a good percentage of the state’s total population from being considered for these state jobs is more than problematic. It is indefensible, given all we now know about COVID-19 and the vaccines’ strengths and limitations. It is indefensible when we know that COVID-19 is most injurious and deadly to people in elderly, not working-age, populations.
This policy is harmful to individuals, the state workforce and taxpayer-funded and -expected services.
A study published in The Lancet finds that the immunity generated from a COVID-19 infection was found to be “at least as high, if not higher” than that provided by two doses of an mRNA vaccine. We’ve known natural immunity plays a role all along in this mandate, yet the governor’s vaccine mandate for state workers does not recognize the value of natural immunity.
The governor is confident his strict COVID-19-related mandates have been responsible for saving lives, but data do not back up these claims.
A comparative look at states shows that some states that did not have vaccine mandates on government employees, or had them but allowed for testing alternatives, have beat Washington when it comes to COVID outcomes. There are many factors in play for good COVID outcomes, including the relative health and age of a state. With so many factors involved, the governor’s bragging is off-target.
Please help end the state’s misguided vaccine mandate on state employees. I am happy to answer any questions or provide you with state-comparative research.
Thank you for your work.”
Elizabeth Hovde is a policy analyst and director of the Centers for Health Care and Worker Rights at the Washington Policy Center. She is a Clark County resident.
Also read:
- Harvest Days in Battle Ground coming up July 19-21The Battle Ground Festivals Association is preparing for three days of celebration, including a car cruise on Friday night, a parade on Saturday, and fireworks on Saturday night at Harvest Days.
- Organizers looking for cars for Cruise to the Shoug show on Aug. 454-40 Brewing Co. is hosting Cruise to the Shoug on Aug. 4 as a fundraiser for the Camas-Washougal Community Chest, and organizers are looking for car owners to book their spots for the show.
- Trump picks Ohio’s J.D. Vance for vice presidentFormer President Donald Trump picked U.S. Sen. J.D. Vance, R-Ohio, to serve as his vice president should Trump beat President Joe Biden this November for another term in the White House.
- Children with disabilities make memories at the 24th annual Merwin Day of FishingOn Saturday (July 13), Pacific Power and the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife joined together to host a memorable fishing event for children with disabilities at the Merwin Fish Hatchery near Woodland.
- Letter: For the public record and the Comprehensive PlanIn a July 12 letter to the Clark County Council, Clark County Citizens United President Susan Rasmussen shares that primary stakeholders were ignored in the Wetland and Habitat Ordinance Conservation Covenant.
- CASE DISMISSED: Classified documents case against Trump thrown out by judgeA federal judge in Florida dismissed the classified documents-related criminal case against former President Donald Trump on Monday, saying the appointment of Special Counsel Jack Smith violated the Constitution.
- Photos: Log show and parade at Territorial Days 2024 in AmboyTerritorial Days in Amboy never disappoints, and this weekend brought all kinds of activities in logging country, and Clark County Today had a photographer there to capture images from the annual parade and log show.