Vancouver resident Julia Dawn Seaver weighs in the proposal to remove the invocation and the Pledge of Allegiance at County Council meetings

Editor’s note: Opinions expressed in this letter to the editor are those of the author alone and do not reflect the editorial position of ClarkCountyToday.com.

If the opening County Council meeting is any indication, the needs of the citizens may not be top of mind for this session.  No sooner had he been sworn in, new councilor Wil Fuentes seemed to indicate his priority is doing away with the invocation and possibly the Pledge of Allegiance at meetings.

Why?  Has there been a clamoring from citizens for such a move?  It seems unlikely, as the other councilors appeared surprised by the suggestion.  No, it appears Fuentes simply has a problem with God being mentioned.  He noted the council meets in a government building where we separate religion and government.  Except we don’t.

From the writings of our founders, to the Declaration of Independence, our currency, and the fact prayer has opened Congressional legislative sessions for the last 250 years, God’s hand has been on this nation from the start.  God or the divine, is mentioned in every one of the 50 state constitutions.

In a 2016 article for The Heritage Foundation, Carson Halloway observed that recent debates around religion focus on the individual’s right to either practice, or to not be exposed to religion.  What’s been lost is an acknowledgment of the benefit religion has on society, as recognized by philosophers such as Plato and Locke. Carson wrote, “Political freedom requires an unshakeable moral foundation that only religion can supply. Moreover, religion is necessary not only to democracy’s emergence, but also to its preservation. Democracy fosters intellectual and moral habits that can be deadly to freedom: the tyranny of the majority, individualism, materialism, and democratic despotism. American Christianity acts as a corrective to these perilous democratic tendencies.”

An overwhelming majority of Americans believe in God.  Asking for a blessing and/or saying the Pledge of Allegiance before meetings can help people with various viewpoints to focus and unify during deliberations. There is no requirement for anyone to believe in God or be present for the invocation or pledge, nor to have any one denomination lead it.  

With citizens continuing to suffer the fallout from progressive economic policies, increased crime, and homelessness, the council plans to use staff and resources to research the invocation and Pledge of Allegiance policies in other communities around the state.  This is a distraction and a waste of resources. The council should focus on the needs of the people, and walk away from a divisive policy that would eliminate these unifying, time-honored traditions.

Julia Dawn Seaver
Vancouver

---

Also read:

• 
  POLL: Is it time for new leadership at Vancouver City Hall?
  A new weekly poll asks whether Vancouver voters should prioritize replacing the mayor and city council in the 2025 election.
• 
  Opinion: How will the majority party’s new budget and tax proposals affect you?
  Rep. John Ley critiques the state’s proposed 2025-27 budgets, warning of record-breaking tax hikes and economic impacts.
• 
  Opinion: Washington’s EV sales far short of next year’s state mandate
  Todd Myers highlights how Washington’s EV sales fall short of next year’s mandate, raising concerns over rising car prices and limited options.
• 
  Letter: ‘Our state and local governments need to learn to live within their means’
  Camas resident Lauren Colas voices strong opposition to Proposition 1 and other tax proposals, calling for state and local governments to rein in spending.
• 
  Opinion: Bill limiting notifications for parents passes committee
  A Washington Policy Center column critiques SB 5181, which would reduce parental notification rights in Washington public schools.