![Photo courtesy Shutterstock](https://www.clarkcountytoday.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/Large_Clark-County-Today-61673a879ab5b-1.jpg)
The high court’s decision is the result of a series of back-and-forth clashes between the plaintiffs and the attorney general
Brett Davis
The Center Square Washington
The Washington Supreme Court on Wednesday morning granted Attorney General Bob Ferguson’s request to allow the state Department of Revenue to collect the capital gains income tax before a final ruling on the tax’s constitutionality next year.
“The Court voted unanimously in favor of the following result: Now, therefore, it is hereby ORDERED: That the motion for a stay of the lower court’s order pending review is granted,” the motion reads. “The lower court order is stayed pending this Court’s final decision in this matter. DATED at Olympia, Washington this 30th day of November, 2022.”
The high court’s decision is the result of a series of back-and-forth clashes between the plaintiffs and the attorney general. On Nov. 21, Ferguson fired back at plaintiffs’ Nov. 16 motion objecting to his office’s request to allow collection of a new capital gains income tax that has been ruled unconstitutional.
The attorney general had filed a motion on Nov. 3 asking the state Supreme Court to allow the DOR to collect the tax before a final ruling on the case.
On July 13, the state Supreme Court agreed to take direct review of the case at Ferguson’s request, bypassing the Court of Appeals, following Douglas County Superior Court Judge Brian Huber’s March 1 ruling the tax adopted last year under Senate Bill 5096 is an unconstitutional graduated income tax.
Huber ruled that the capital gains income tax “is declared unconstitutional and invalid, and therefore, is void and inoperable as a matter of law.”
Aimed at Washington’s wealthiest residents, the new tax adds a 7% tax on capital gains above $250,000 a year, such as profits from stocks or business sales. Exceptions include the sale of real estate, livestock, and small family-owned businesses.
Citizen Action Defense Fund Executive Director Jackson Maynard was not happy about the substance of the court’s Wednesday morning decision, but did find a silver lining.
“While we are disappointed in the Court’s ruling today, the fact that the State was forced to follow proper procedure demonstrates that no one – even a state agency – is above the law,” he said in a statement. “CADF was clearly right in insisting that the Department needed to get a motion to stay the trial court ruling and couldn’t just ignore it.
On October 5, the local government watchdog nonprofit sent the DOR a letter demanding the agency stop its rulemaking activities related to implementing the tax, maintaining that because the state did not ask to stay the lower court ruling, the statute was void.
“The Department in the Motion to Stay dropped any pretense that its proposed rules were just ‘guidance’ – the State’s filings demonstrate that it planned to collect the tax all along,” Maynard continued. “We are pleased that the parties cited our letters and those of legislators who were also concerned about the Department’s actions as part of the record in this matter. We look forward to the Court’s continued review of the merits of this case and this unconstitutional tax in the coming months.”
Although the state did eventually file a motion to stay the trial court ruling, the DOR responded to the letter by claiming that its proposed rules were guidance and would not be binding unless the state Supreme Court upheld the tax.
The state Supreme Court is set to hear oral arguments in the case, Chris Quinn, et al. vs. State of Washington, on Jan. 26, 2023.
This report was first published by The Center Square Washington.
Also read:
- Harvest Days in Battle Ground coming up July 19-21The Battle Ground Festivals Association is preparing for three days of celebration, including a car cruise on Friday night, a parade on Saturday, and fireworks on Saturday night at Harvest Days.
- Organizers looking for cars for Cruise to the Shoug show on Aug. 454-40 Brewing Co. is hosting Cruise to the Shoug on Aug. 4 as a fundraiser for the Camas-Washougal Community Chest, and organizers are looking for car owners to book their spots for the show.
- Trump picks Ohio’s J.D. Vance for vice presidentFormer President Donald Trump picked U.S. Sen. J.D. Vance, R-Ohio, to serve as his vice president should Trump beat President Joe Biden this November for another term in the White House.
- Children with disabilities make memories at the 24th annual Merwin Day of FishingOn Saturday (July 13), Pacific Power and the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife joined together to host a memorable fishing event for children with disabilities at the Merwin Fish Hatchery near Woodland.
- Letter: For the public record and the Comprehensive PlanIn a July 12 letter to the Clark County Council, Clark County Citizens United President Susan Rasmussen shares that primary stakeholders were ignored in the Wetland and Habitat Ordinance Conservation Covenant.
- CASE DISMISSED: Classified documents case against Trump thrown out by judgeA federal judge in Florida dismissed the classified documents-related criminal case against former President Donald Trump on Monday, saying the appointment of Special Counsel Jack Smith violated the Constitution.
- Photos: Log show and parade at Territorial Days 2024 in AmboyTerritorial Days in Amboy never disappoints, and this weekend brought all kinds of activities in logging country, and Clark County Today had a photographer there to capture images from the annual parade and log show.